id please

[hartt0987]

Can you id this please

 

[hartt0987]

View attachment 11228
View attachment 11229

 

[Herbie]

pineapple sponge or a feather duster. google image those and lett us know.

 

[hartt0987]

Definitly not a feather duster i have a few of those elsewere on the rocks, pineapple sponge possibly

 

[DAS212]

it looks translucent were the pineapple's are a milky white. Can you get another pic

 

[hartt0987]

View attachment 11308
Yes they are translucent no reaction to movement or light either, theres a couple of them, they look like they go into the rock, also id on the other one thats circled please, thank you

 

[fwadiver]

orange/brown is some kinda paly they could be vermited snails, their tubes appear clear when they first move, can you break them off? are they hard and pokey or soft. you will be able to tell if sponge right away.