Hmmm so maybe push down on the impeller harder?
Sent from my SPH-L720T using Tapatalk
No, get a new impeller. When you take the impeller out can you spin the plastic part independently of the magnet? If so, you can try super glue to fix it temporarily, but will need a replacement.
If you need a backup pump in the meantimes I have one you can use. Your tank cannot go without water movement. How old is the pump? Is it under warrantee?