What is this

Does that mean I can have that sweet nem you have on order?

Don't be discouraged, this isn't a big deal, just gotta fix it and move on.

If it was on ONE piece of rock it wouldn't be a big deal, but it's like on 3. I have big rock for my tank, and really can't afford to get new rock. Knowing my luck, the hydroids have already laid their larvae in my tank and I'll get new rock and the rock I have in there will be infested. :(

I feel like crying right now (probably because I'm an over emotional pregnant woman).

I'll try taking it out and scraping them off, with some of the rock.. But we'll see what happens. :\ Finding my Goby is what I'm worried about. He's hiding from me.

As much as you'd like my sweet nem - I am going to at least TRY and fix this. If it goes sour I'll let you know.
 
If it was on ONE piece of rock it wouldn't be a big deal, but it's like on 3. I have big rock for my tank, and really can't afford to get new rock. Knowing my luck, the hydroids have already laid their larvae in my tank and I'll get new rock and the rock I have in there will be infested. :(

I feel like crying right now (probably because I'm an over emotional pregnant woman).

I'll try taking it out and scraping them off, with some of the rock.. But we'll see what happens. :\ Finding my Goby is what I'm worried about. He's hiding from me.

As much as you'd like my sweet nem - I am going to at least TRY and fix this. If it goes sour I'll let you know.

About how many pounds of rock would you guesstimate needs to be replaced that is infested? Il its not all that much, it should be pretty easy to find a few rocks really cheap if you post up in the want to buy forum. Quite a few people have been getting rid of rock lately.
 
About how many pounds of rock would you guesstimate needs to be replaced that is infested? Il its not all that much, it should be pretty easy to find a few rocks really cheap if you post up in the want to buy forum. Quite a few people have been getting rid of rock lately.

I have no idea - I'm really bad at that. And obviously it can't be trusted! Lol. This rock was from someone else, and it wasn't there when I saw it in his tank. Came a while after my tank cycled.

This is a pretty big piece of rock (for my 28). And I'd want a sililar piece because I like my aquascape. I'd say there's only 25% of my sand bed covered.
 
Copperband's imo are hit or miss. Had one im my tank to control aptaisia and he didn't touch them. Not to mention they are a difficult fish to keep long term.
 
wait. Colonial hydroids do not explode in population, and tend to stay on a piece of rock you got them on. Are we talking about aptasia's or hydroids. they are completely different, picture will help cecily
 
like i said earlier, they are "common" on live rock, and really don't do any damage unless you see jellyfish looking brittle starfish (they are sperming your tank), or your coral around them are closed up, and thus they are stinging that coral.

same really goes for aptasia, i just read on a tank on reefbuilders that does 100% natural light in south africa, and uses aptasia tank under for a filter....so they do eat crap.

just ugly buggers, not really 100% bad in every instance.

Natural approach before you KALK your tank unnecessarily, my mythrax crab killed my colony off pretty quick. hit or miss omnivores though.

http://www.xtalworld.com/Aquarium/hitchfaq.htm
I've used this simple diagram a million times to see what's bad and good, they really do say right on there as i re-read it what i said, bad next to coral. This is a good bookmark for the newer people.
 
IMO (based on pictures/description) they are one of the thousands species of colonial hydroids. IMO they are a huge neusance that will quickly take over every inch of your tank. Not all, but many can sting corals.

My research/experience with them:
In my 57 I started with 3 small patches about the size of a dime on my liverock. I had 3 different types of hydroids. I had 60+ lbs of liverock, so I didnt think much of them because they were in such a tiny area.

2 of the species grew fairly slow. After 3 months of growth, the dime sized area became a quarter sized area. I decided I didn't want them growing anymore, so I took a knife and scratched the area really good for 5 minutes. Never saw them again.

The 3rd species i had was another story.
Common name is pompom hydroids because, well, they look a little like pompoms.
Here is a picture:
pom%20Coral%20ID.jpg


These hydroids entangle into the rockwork like tree roots and new heads were always popping out of the roots. I went from about 20 to thousands in only a few months. In my experience, nothing eats them. I tried peppermint shrimp, keyhole limpets, bhergia nudi's, and a copperband. Pretty much everything that may eat it, and no luck. I tried kalk and glueing over, but it never killed the roots in the rockwork. In a few days/hours they would just reappear. I took my rocks out and took a mini torch to them. Burned the whole areas good, killed off some coraline and sponges though. Looked good for 2 weeks, but then they just came back in full force like I never did anything. I tried manual removal in tank, but if one floated away it just started another colony elsewhere. The hardest part was the 'roots' which went inside the liverock and were next to impossible to completely exterminate.
I eventually took off all my corals and threw out all of my rock. I had to drain my tank and clean it because a few hydroids were on the overflow box and it only takes a few to become thousands in notime.

Sorry, but if it were me I would save the time and hassle and throw out anything that may have hydroids on them. I was much happier and more relieved when I just threw all the rock away and started over. Maybe someone else has had better experiences, but for me any many others online, it was better to just toss everything. You have to make sure you get every single one though...Its tough because some may be on the sand, glass, overflow, coral bottoms, powerheads, ect.
They are probably so infused and webbed in your liverock that complete eradication is probably very hard. Yours look a little different than mine so I am not sure. There are thousands of species, and we know relatively little about them.
 
Has this problem been rectified, Cecily?

Actually - not completely.. but I just plucked them off with some tweezers after doing some research. Never got around to super gluing over the area they were at.. but the knew I plucked haven't come back and its been a good month.

I didn't have the rapidly spreading ones.

Sent from Cecily's G2x using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top